Ingredient missing

Taste

Look

Smell

Texture

None

A bit like peanut butter with chocolate chips mixed in.

Flat and dark brown bottom, round and light brown top with chocolate chips

*Mostly burnt* but a bit cookie doughy-ish and it smelled like melted chocolate.

(*Because we left them in too long by mistake*)

Rough and uneven.

Flour

Not sweet, sour, yucky, yucky, yucky!

Like poop and also like bubbling butter with melted chocolate chips.

Warm, melted dark chocolate

Like toffee, kind of chewy

White sugar

Bitter and a bit like play dough.

Like a normal cookie.

Bitter and like play dough.

Like a normal cookie.

Brown sugar

Bitter

Like a normal cookie

Like a normal cookie

Like a normal cookie

Margarine

The same as a normal cookie but just a little bit different. (Their is a very subtle difference that it is hard to explain)

A little flatter than a normal cookie

Like a normal cookie

Like a normal cookie

Egg

Uncooked (like dough)

Pale, clumpy, out of shape and the dough never changed in the oven

The same as a normal cookie

Powdery, crumbly, it was impossible to make the dough stick together, it was to dry.

Baking soda

The same as a normal cookie

The same as a normal cookie

Like cookie dough flavored ice cream and like chocolate.

The same as a normal cookie

Vanilla

A tad saltier, the dough also tasted a tad less sweet

Same as normal cookie

Same as normal cookie

Same as normal cookie

Salt

Same as normal cookie

Same as normal cookie

Same as normal cookie

Same as normal cookie

Shortening

Not as sweet as a normal cookie, a weird hard-to-explain (some people think it’s bad) taste

The same as a normal cookie

The same as a normal cookie

The same as a normal cookie

Both white and brown sugar

Like play dough and very salty and the dough tasted like play dough too

Round bottom, didn’t get bigger in the oven

Like play dough

A bit powdery